“The Spirit Level” debate

July 23rd, 2010 by Roger Darlington

I’ve already blogged several times about a fascinating book called “The Spirit Level” by Richard Wilkinson & Kate Pickett. In my review of the work, I commented: “This is one of the most important books that I have read in five decades of reading because its scope is so wide and its message so compelling and because it resonates powerfully with my own political principles and passion for social justice.”

The central proposition of the book is that, in the more developed countries of  the world, the more unequal the income distribution the more that nation suffers from a range of poor social outcomes.

This week I attended a debate at the Royal Society of Arts in London in which the two authors of “The Spirit Level” were challenged by two critics of their work, Christopher Snowden, author of “The Spirit Level Delusion”, and Peter Saunders, author of “Beware False Prophets”. The whole thing will be podcast here.

The critics presented three main arguments.

1) The data used is selective in terms of countries and that a small number of outliers distorts the apparent correlation.  RW & KP argued that they consistently used the same 23 nations for which robust data was available  in order not to be accused of selectivity and that the predictive power of their thesis had been demonstrated by new data for additional countries fitting well the correlations.

2) That the thesis does not take proper account of cultural and historical factors which would better explain why the Scandinavian countries appear to do so well and the Anglo nations seem to do so badly. RW & KP pointed out that the same correlations are found in the 50 states of the USA which share a common culture and history.

3) That the influence of third variables has not be considered so that, for instance, for the US data ethnicity is a more powerful predictor of homicide rates that income distribution. This begs the question of whether in any given state there are more murders because there are more African-Americans or because there are more black people who happen to be poor.

Pickett was particularly confident and convincing in her presentation and answers and said that on Monday the web site of the Equality Trust would carry a detailed rebuttal of all the criticisms made of the book. She was the one of the four speakers who reminded the packed-out lecture theatre that we are dealing with human issues: “We are talking about human suffering here”.

My overall conclusion was that Snowden & Saunders had raised sufficient methodical and computational issues to suggest that the original thesis may not be as simple or as powerful as the book asserts, but that the central proposition remains valid and strong. More research and debate would be valuable, and politicians and policymakers need to examine how best countries can reduce inequalities of income and wealth.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)


The Battle of Britain (2): the Americans

July 22nd, 2010 by Roger Darlington

“I think it is important in life to speak as it is and the fact is that we are a very effective partner of the US but we are the junior partner. We were the junior partner in 1940 when we were fighting the Nazis.”

British Prime Minister David Cameron speaking to Sky television

This year is the 70th anniversary of the Battle of Britain in 1940. The Royal Air Force roll of honour for the Battle recognises 595 non-British pilots (out of 2,936) as flying at least one authorised operational sortie with an eligible unit of the RAF between 10 July and 31 October 1940.

That means that one in five of the RAF pilots were not British. But only seven of them were American because, of course, the USA did not enter the war until December 1941.

I’m sure the Prime Minister meant to say something different but he needs to be more careful on such sensitive matters.

Posted in History | Comments (1)


The great city of London

July 20th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

My wife and I visited the Museum of London today. Amazingly she has never been there before and I wanted to go again because they have recently opened five new galleries on the period since 1666. In all, there are nine permanent galleries telling the story of this great city over two millennia.

My favourite gallery is the one called “War, Plague & Fire” which covers the period 1550s-1660s – a turbulent time that encompassed the English Civil War which led to the execution of King Charles I, the Great Plague which killed a fifth of the population (100,000), and the Great Fire of London which raged for five days and destroyed a third of the city.

The Museum of London has just launched an iPhone app which I’ve downloaded – information here.

While we were in the area, we looked into the Postman’s Park, a tribute to the heroism of working people, and viewed the Marconi plaque, a commemoration of the first broadcasting of radio signals.

Posted in History | Comments (0)


The truth about Communism

July 19th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

It’s two decades now since the collapse of the Communist regimes in Central & Eastern Europe but we sometimes need to remind ourselves of the terrible human cost of those repressive systems.

Today saw the publication of the obituary by a friend of mine of one of the victims of Communist totalitarianism in what was then Czechoslovakia, the birthplace of my wife’s father. She was Marian Rose Šlingová-Fagan and you can read about her life here.

Posted in History | Comments (0)


Farewell (for now) Jonathan Ross

July 18th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

I’ve only just watched a recording of this week’s “Friday Night With Jonathan Ross” show on BBC television. As the BBC have not renewed his contract, it was his last such show. He interviewed Mickey Rourke, Jackie Chan and David Beckham and song was provided by Roxy Music.

I’m a big fan of Jonathan Ross and believe that he is the best presenter on British television – warm, funny and knowledgeable.

What he did in relation to Andrew Sachs was utterly wrong and he paid the price financially and professionally. Before the Sachs affair, his on-air humour could be a bit too salacious but he scaled it back.

So I’m really sorry to see him leave our screens and Friday nights will be the poorer for it but, after a a sabbatical, he’ll be back next year on ITV and I’ll be watching.

Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)


The American dilemma

July 18th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

From a non-American perspective, President Barack Obama seems to have done well in his first year and a half in the White House. He has managed to push through Congress three huge measures: an economic stimulus package, major healthcare reform, and a restructuring of the financial sector.

And yet, and yet, his poll ratings are so low. Some Democrats think that he has not been radical enough, while many Republicans think that he is dangerously Left-wing.

This is well-described in this article.

The problem is that Obama can do little without Congress and Congress is a legislative quagmire with Republicans refusing to support presidential initiatives and even many Democrats demanding amendments that weaken the proposals. There are two main reasons for this.

Reason one is the constitution. The Founding Fathers designed this so that power is distributed between the executive, the legislature and the judiciary. This may have made sense two centuries ago when the fear was an all-powerful centre like the King in Britain whose tyranny the Americans had just overthrown.  It makes no sense in the 21st century when the USA is a superpower and political problems demand speedy and radical solutions.

Reason two is money. It is virtually impossible for anyone to be elected to office in the USA without spending sums of money that would be considered obscene in most democracies. And this money come from the vested interests – financial institutions, energy companies, private health companies – that are opposed to any change that would challenge their profits and benefit the majority of Americans.

To change the rules on political funding would mean electing more independent-minded Congress men and women but they can’t get elected without a ton of money from the companies that like to be able to buy power and block change. Catch 22. Ah yes, that famous American novel.

Posted in American current affairs | Comments (3)


The Darlington Spitfire

July 17th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

In 1985, William Kimber published “Night Hawk”, my biography of Flight Lieutenant Karel Kuttelwascher, the RAF’s greatest night intruder ace [for more information click here]. While doing picture research for this book at the Imperial War Museum in London, I came across a photograph of “The Darlington Spitfire”. Given my surname, I was naturally intrigued and began to research the record of this particular aircraft.

I found that it had spent no less than three and a half years with the wartime RAF, in that time serving with six operational squadrons and making a total of 161 recorded sorties. Its victory score was three enemy aircraft destroyed, another three and a half probable, and one damaged.

The monograph which resulted from these researches was completed in October 1986. It was too long for an article and too short for a book. Therefore, for 13 years, it rested unseen in my study. However, when I started a web site in 1999, I was able to put the full text online here.

In fact, that same year Peter Caygill – a resident of Darlington in County Durham – produced the book that I would love to have written. Entitled “The Darlington Spitfire: A Charmed Life”, it was published by Airlife Publishing Ltd.

One the RAF pilots who flew “The Darlington Spitfire” was Roy Flight. He was her regular pilot at 118 Squadron and, over a period of two months, she carried him into battle on a total of 26 operations, never failing to bring him back unharmed. You can find my account of this period in sections five to seven of my essay.

I was absolutely delighted to receive an e-mail this week from a neighbour of Roy Flight who assures me that he is still alive and well, now a retired doctor aged 86 living on the North Island of New Zealand.

Posted in History | Comments (6)


My 22nd short story

July 16th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Today I’ve put on my web site my latest short story. It’s entitled “Time To Move On” and you can read it here.

Please let me know what you think.

This short story is my 22nd effort. If you’ve missed any the others, you can access them all here.

Posted in My life & thoughts | Comments (2)


Forgotten World (215): Council of Europe

July 16th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

The Council of Europe – headquartered in Strasbourg, France – is not to be confused with the European Union. The Council was formed in 1949 to promote human rights on the continent, while the European Union – as it is now called – was created in 1957 to encourage economic and political union. The EU now has 27 Member States, but the Council has 47, including every European country except Belarus.

The greatest achievement of the Council of Europe is the European Convention on Human Rights – often wrongly associated with the European Union.  The last Labour Government incorporated the provisions of the Convention into UK domestic law which means that it can be enforced in British courts, but the Conservative Party has called for it to be replaced by a specifically British Bill of Rights.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)


It’s St Swithin’s Day

July 15th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Here in the UK, today – 15 July – is known as St Swithin’s Day. And what is all that about, I hear my non-British readers asking.

Well, the story goes that, if we have rain or sun on this day, then we will have the same weather for the next 40 days. You can read a fuller explanation here.

Of course, the whole thing is nonsense, but it reflects the British near-obsession with our weather.

Note 1: It’s been raining here in London today so maybe we’ll have a lot of rain in the next month or so.

Note 2: In the first six months of this year, Britain experienced the driest first half of the calendar year since 1914, so maybe we need more rain.

Note 3: The most recent novel that I’ve read is called “One Day” and that day, revisited each 12 months for 20 years, is St Swithin’s Day – you can read my review of the novel here.

Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)