Moral complexity in WW2 (1): ‘Operation Catapult’

May 29th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

At the beginning of the Second World War, British Prime Minister Winston felt compelled to order the Royal Navy to attack the pride of the French naval fleet in ‘Operation Catapult’, an assault which caused some 1,300 deaths and around 350 injuries – all of them citizens of France, our leading ally in the struggle against Nazi Germany. It happened at the North African port of Mers-el-Kébir in the late afternoon of 3 July 1940.
This was arguably the toughest decision that Churchill had to take in the course of the war and may well have been decisive in denying the French vessels to the Germans and in convincing the Americans of Britain’s determination to resist Hitler. But the chances are that you’ve never heard of the incident.
I’ve known about the operation for a long time because I came across it while researching for a book I wrote some 25 years ago. It was a biography of my wife’s father Karel Kuttelwascher, a Czech pilot who at this stage of the war was close to Mers-el-Kébir with the French III/3 Squadron. The squadron flew a couple of sorties over the port just after the British attack but none of the Czechs with the squadron was allowed to fly that day because they were felt to have divided loyalties, since the Battle of France had been lost and the Czechs were planning to escape to Britain to continue the fight.
I was reminded of ‘Operation Catapult’ this week when Channel Four screened a documentary called “Churchill’s Darkest Decision”. The programme featured both British and French naval crew involved in the event and underlined the morally complex decisions that have to be made in war.

Posted in History | Comments (0)


Moral complexity in WW2 (2): Israel Kasztner

May 29th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

Many of you will have read the book “Schindler’s Ark” or seen the film “Schindler’s List” and know how the Czech businessman Oscar Schindler managed to affect the escape of almost 1,200 Jews from Poland so that they missed certain death in the Nazi concentration camps of World War Two. But what about the Hungarian Jewish businessman Israel Kasztner who negotiated with Adolf Eichmann in Hungary to enable almost 1,700 Jews to escape the gas chambers. This was the largest single group to be saved from the Holocaust – but I’m guessing that you’ve never heard of the incident.
This is because historically Israel Kasztner has been a hugely controversial figure, no more so that in Israel itself where he was a Government Minister after the war and the subject of an infamous court trial before he was assassinated outside his home in Tel Aviv. His critics argue that he was a Nazi collaborator; his defenders believe that he no choice but to negotiate with the Germans if he was to enable any Jews to leave Hungary alive.
This week I saw a fascinating BBC4 television programme entitled “The Jew Who Dealt With The Nazis”. Among those interviewed were Kasztner’s daughter, one of his grand-daughters and the man who assassinated him. The programme brought out very clearly how morally complex was the position of Jewish leaders in Occupied Europe as they struggled to comprehend what today we call the Holocaust and to do what they could to give some Jews a chance to live.
Of course, the Holocaust raises so many moral issues and a good introduction to this huge subject can be found in the book reviewed here.

Posted in History | Comments (0)


Back online (again)

May 28th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

Regular visitors to NightHawk will know about my time off-line when I lost my Internet connection and it took about 20 calls to Pipex and 10 days for my connection to be restored. For the next two weeks, things worked like a dream.
Then, about mid-day on Tuesday, I lost my connection AGAIN. Either Pipex are upping their game or I was more persistent or I was just plain lucky, but this time it only took two calls and two days to restore the connection.
By the law of averages, I should now have fault-free service for at least a decade. Let’s see …

Posted in My life & thoughts | Comments (3)


Does the British political system need reform?

May 26th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

Of course, it does – and, spurred by understandable outrage over MPs’ expenses, all sorts of proposals are being mooted. Today the leader of the Conservative Party David Cameron contributes a major article in the “Guardian” newspaper of all places.
So I’ve taken the opportunity to up-date my essay “A Short Guide To The British Political System” to list some of the main reforms that have been suggested.

Posted in British current affairs | Comments (1)


How many times have I blogged?

May 25th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

I don’t know the exact answer.
But I’ve been running my personal blog NightHawk for six years and my professional blog CommsWatch for five and half years. I have precise figures for the past three years when I moved to my current hosting location and I can make a fairly good estimate for the entire period of my blogging experience.
I reckon that I’ve now done around 4,000 postings.

Posted in Internet | Comments (0)


Humour around the world

May 25th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

Here in the UK, today is a Bank Holiday, so I thought that I’d do a lighthearted posting (if you don’t live in Britain, don’t worry – this is a posting with an international dimension).
I’m currently reading a book called “Quirkology” by Professor Richard Wiseman. One of the chapters is about why people find jokes funny. He writes about an experiment he conducted to find the world’s funniest jokes and to establish which jokes were found funniest by different nationalities. Check out the results here.
Wiseman is a briliant communicator and I have heard him speak a couple of times [postings here and here].

Posted in Miscellaneous | Comments (0)


An audio guide to London

May 24th, 2009 by Roger Darlington

London is one of my favourite cities and the one where I have lived for the last 38 years as I’ve written on my web site here.
I always like to learn more about the numerous sites of the city and my attention has recently been drawn to this audio guide to London.

Posted in My life & thoughts | Comments (0)


A brief guide to magic medicine

May 23rd, 2009 by Roger Darlington

My views are captured completely in this guide
So why do people believe in these so-called alternative therapies? – see my explanation here.
Clearly none of these therapies has passed the sort of double blind test that I am currently trialling with the polypill – see here.

Posted in Science & technology | Comments (0)


How strong is al-Qaida?

May 22nd, 2009 by Roger Darlington

“In the final analysis, al-Qaida is more of a security nuisance than a strategic threat. Al-Qaida has shown itself to be its own worst enemy and is in a process of self-decomposition.”

This is the conclusion of a thoughtful and evidence-based piece by Fawaz A Gerges, author of “The Far Enemy: Why Jihad Went Global”. Obviously we should not be complacent, but equally we should not exaggerate the threat or the support of ordinary Muslims.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)


Forgotten World (175): Thailand

May 22nd, 2009 by Roger Darlington

What was then called Siam was the only south-east Asian country not to be occupied by a European power and in 1932 the nation became Thailand after a bloodless revolution created a constitutional monarchy. Since then, there have been 18 military coups, the last in 2006 which deposed the then Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra. The country of 63 million is highly divided between the Thaksin-supporting poor and a wealthy Bangkok elite.
The capital Bangkok – known in Thai as Krung Thep Mahanakhon – expanded rapidly with the influx of workers during the boom years and it is one of Asia’s most vibrant, and heavily-congested, cities with a population of 8 million. The large-scale sex industry which flourishes there contributed to the incidence of HIV infection – a major concern for the Thai government.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)