A review of the 2017 film “The Circle”
January 22nd, 2021 by Roger Darlington
Based on Dave Eggers’ best-selling novel, this movie explains how a powerful information technology company with a huge worldwide customer base – the Circle of the title – plans to introduce a series of clever innovations that seem to solve a social or political ill and introduce transparency and accountability but massively undermine personal space and individual liberty while defying any public or political control.
In the words of the public face of the company Eamon Bailey (Tom Hanks – and who wouldn’t trust him?): “Knowing is good, but knowing everything is better”. Completely taken in by the company’s vision is young newcomer Mae Holland (Emma Watson) who declares: “Secrets are lies. Secrets make crimes possible… Secrets need accountability”.
I thoroughly enjoyed the book but, in spite of some fine leading actors, the story does not seem to work so well on the screen as the shortness of time makes for a simplification of the arguments and the lack of drama is more noticeable in a film.
Link: my review of the book click here
Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)
“A Promised Land” by Barack Obama (4)
January 22nd, 2021 by Roger Darlington
There is a famous quote, usually – but wrongly – attributed to the German politician Otto von Bismarck, which was in fact written by the American poet John Godfrey Saxe: “Laws, like sausages, cease to inspire respect in proportion as we know how they are made”.
This observation was in my mind as I read the 50 pages which Obama devotes to explaining the tortuous process which finally led to the enactment of his signature legislative achievement: the Affordable Care Act (ACA) often called Obamacare.
To most non-Americans, the case for reform would look compelling: in spite of the US spending a lot more money per person on healthcare than any other advanced economy, the results were similar or worse and, in spite of Medicare for seniors and Medicaid for the poor, more than 43 million Americans were uninsured.
Even Obama thought the argument was powerful: “When I think back to those early conversations, it’s hard to deny my overconfidence. I was convinced that the logic of healthcare reform was so obvious that even in the face of well-organized opposition I could rally the American people’s support”.
But the legislative process in the US is much more complicated than in other democratic nations, mainly because of the constitutional dispersal of power, the financial clout of lobbyists and campaign funders, and the bitterest political divide in the nation since the civil war.
So the process took over a year and the Bill of 906 pages was only passed with a final vote margin of seven. Even then, a substantial series of compromises was forced on Obama, such as abandonment of ‘the public option’.
But, in spite of four years of Trump’s efforts to destroy Obamacare, it survives and President Biden now has a foundation on which he can build.
Posted in American current affairs | Comments (0)
What are the 17 executive orders signed by newly-inaugurated President Joe Biden?
January 21st, 2021 by Roger Darlington
A couple of months ago, I did a posting explaining the role of executive orders in the American political system and suggesting that, once in the Oval Office, Joe Biden would enact a slew of such orders to undo some of the worst features of the Trump presidency.
So it has proved to be. But what have these 17 executive orders done? In summary:
Mandate federal employees and contractors to wear masks
Re-enter the World Trade Organisation
Restructure the federal government’s Covid-19 response
Extend moratorium on home eviction and foreclosure
Extend freeze on student loan repayments
Rejoin the Paris climate accord
Restore environmental regulations
Root out systemic racism in federal government programmes and and institutions
Restore counting of non-citizens in US census
Preserve and fortifying protections for Dreamers
Reverse the travel bad on 13 Muslim-majority countries
Repeal of Trump executive order on interior enforcement
Stop construction of the wall on the US-Mexico border
Defer enforced departure for Liberians
Prevent and combat discrimination on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation
Mandate an ethics pledge for executive branch appointees
Restore regulatory actions by the government curbed by Trump
You can find more information on these 17 executive orders here.
Posted in American current affairs | Comments (0)
A review of the 2019 documentary “Knock Down The House”
January 20th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
This documentary looks at a little-covered feature of American politics – primaries for the House of Representatives – from an unusual viewpoint – that of four progressive female candidates challenging the establishment incumbents.
Directed by Rachel Lears, it follows the 2018 insurgency campaigns of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) of New York, Amy Vilela of Nevada, Cori Bush of Missouri, and Paula Jean Swearengin of West Virginia. Only AOC was successful, defeating Democratic Caucus Chair Joe Crowley, a 10-term incumbent (she went on to become, at 29, the youngest ever member of Congress).
However, what the film demonstrates is the passionate commitment of all four women and the phenomenal work involved in a grassroots political campaign.
Catch it on Netflix
Posted in American current affairs | Comments (0)
A review of the 1949 film “All The King’s Men”
January 16th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
This classic film – which was remade in 2006 – is based on a novel by Pulitzer Prize-winning author Robert Penn Warren published in 1946. It tells the story of the rise to power of charismatic and populist Willie Stark (Broderick Crawford) who storms his way to becoming Governor of a Southern US state in the Depression era.
Along the way, a host of characters, including narrator and political journalist Jack Burden (John Ireland) and campaign assistant Sadie Burke (Mercedes McCambridge), bend to his will, even when knowing just how venal and corrupt he is. The movie won three Academy Awards – one for Best Picture and others for Crawford and McCambridge – but nothing for writer, producer and director Robert Rossen.
At the time of the film’s release, viewers would have seen in the morality tale a reflection of the career of Louisiana governor Huey Long. Today, so much of the dialogue and so many plot points seem eerily prescient as the playbook of President Donald Trump.
Towards the end of the film, Stark is impeached by the state’s House of Representatives and, as the Senate decides whether to uphold the charge, it is surrounded by baying, ultra-loyal Stark supporters. It is entirely a coincidence – it just happened to be on television – that I caught this movie the week that Trump fanatics stormed the Capitol and Trump was impeached (for the second time) by the House.
Jack Burden explains how it’s done: “Appeal to their emotions. Make them laugh; make them cry; make them mad, even if they get mad at you. But for heaven’s sake, don’t try to improve their minds.” And Sadie Burke states of her boss: “He’ll ditch everybody in the whole world, because that’s what Willie wants. Nobody in the world but him!”
Remind you of anybody?
Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)
“A Promised Land” by Barack Obama (3)
January 15th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
Barack Obama’s presidency began at the height of the subprime mortgage fiasco in the housing market which occasioned a triple economic crisis: the worst recession since the Great Depression, a near collapse of the banking system, and an impending bankruptcy of America’s leading car manufacturers. The stock market had lost 40% of its value and unemployment would eventually reach 10%.
The recession was addressed by the 1,073-page American Recovery and Reinvestment Act which was passed in the first month with “precisely zero Republican votes” in the House and just three GOP votes in the Senate in spite of Obama’s heroic efforts to reach across the aisle.
The housing crisis was countered by the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP) and the Home Affordable Refinance Program (HARP). The banking system held up following a bold formula of institutional stress tests carried out by the Federal Reserve. And the car industry survived with General Motors being restructured and Chrysler going into partnership with Fiat.
Obama acknowledges that “my administration’s handling of the financial crisis still generates fierce debate“. He explains that: “For many thoughtful critics … the fact that I had engineered a return to pre-crisis normalcy is precisely the problem – a missed opportunity if not an outright betrayal”.
He is honest with readers: “I wonder whether I should have been bolder in those early months”. But he concludes: “my first hundred days in office revealed a basic strand of my political character. I was a reformer, conservative in temperament if not in vision”.
Posted in American current affairs | Comments (0)
Just how deadly was 2020?
January 14th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
“Official statistics released on Tuesday showed 2020 was the deadliest year in England and Wales for more than a century. More than 608,000 people died last year, 81,653 of whom as a result of coronavirus.
Deaths exceeded 600,000 for only the second time on record, and the toll was just behind that of 611,861 in 1918, the worst year of the flu pandemic.”
This is a quote from an article in today’s “Guardian” newspaper.
Posted in British current affairs | Comments (0)
How do the political systems of the United States and the United Kingdom compare with one another?
January 13th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
As the US House of Representatives considers a (second) impeachment of President Donald Trump, many are observing the procedures of the US Congressional system. The majority of visitors to this blog are British or American. So how do the political systems of the two nations compare?
You can check out my comparison here.
Elsewhere on this web site, I have outlined in some detail explanations of both the American political system [click here] and the British political system [click here].
Posted in American current affairs, British current affairs | Comments (0)
“A Promised Land” by Barack Obama (2)
January 11th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
Each time we go into lockdown, I find a really long book to read. In this third lockdown, I’m working my way through the first volume of Barack Obama’s presidential memoirs. In fact, it is 200 pages into the 700 page text before he wins the presidency.
First, he tells us about his time at Columbia University in New York, his work as a community organiser in Chicago, his studies at Harvard Law School, his period as a Illinois state senator, and his unsuccessful attempt to enter the House of Representatives. He is frank about the strain that his political ambition put on his marriage to Michelle. He admits that “we began arguing more” with “my marriage strained”.
Yet, two years after his defeat, he runs for the US Senate – a decision he acknowledges represents “brashness” and “sheer chutzpah” – and wins easily in a race that “felt charmed”. Fascinatingly, one of his initiatives in the Senate was “funding to safeguard against a pandemic outbreak”.
As if such a meteoric rise was not enough, just two years into what should have been his first six-year term as a senator, Obama decided to have a go at the White House. In these memoirs, he spends more space describing the tough battle to win the Democratic nomination against Hillary Clinton (85 pages) than he does narrating his easier fight in the general election against John McCain ( 50 pages).
Posted in American current affairs | Comments (0)
A review of the 1959 classic film “Ben-Hur”
January 10th, 2021 by Roger Darlington
Astonishingly this movie was nominated for no less than 12 Academy Awards and managed to win 11 of them, a feat not equalled until “Titanic” 40 years later. I say astonishingly because it is really not that good.
The cinematography in Panavision is wonderful and the chariot race is genuinely exciting, but the plotting is slow, most of the dialogue is leaden and a fair bit of the acting is forced, while the appearance of Jesus and the incidence of a miracle appear out of sorts with today’s more secular days. Nevertheless, at the time, the film was a great commercial success which saved MGM from bankruptcy.
Based on a 19th century novel by civil war general Lew Wallace, it is a strong story of conflict between former childhood friends, Roman officer Messala (Stephen Boyd) and Jewish dignatory Judah Ben-Hur in Roman-occupied Judea at the time of Christ.
At some three and a half hours, the material before and after the chariot race should have been shortened, but the race itself was a triumph for winner of three Best Director Academy Awards, William Wallace. It required 15,000 extras on a set constructed on 18 acres at Cinecitta Studios outside Rome and it took five weeks to film.
Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)