Who sank the “Cheonan”?

June 6th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

This weekend, we visited our Chinese ‘family’ and together we went round to see other Chinese friends including one who has a PhD on China’s role in the United Nations Security Council. As well as deep friendship, I always enjoy seeing our Chinese friends because it gives me an insight into a very different culture and a very different way of looking at the world.

This time, I raised the issue of why China is being so supportive of North Korea in spite of provocations like the sinking of the South Korean ship the “Cheonan” with the loss of 46 lives. To my surprise, my Chinese friends were not convinced that the North Koreans were responsible for the sinking.

The Wikipedia essay on the incident notes:

“On May 20, the investigation team (South Korea, U.S., U.K., Sweden, Australia and Canada) released their report in which they concluded that the sinking of the warship was in fact the result of a North Korean torpedo attack, commenting that “The evidence points overwhelmingly to the conclusion that the torpedo was fired by a North Korean submarine.” The inquiry also found that a group of small submarines, escorted by a support ship, departed from a North Korean naval base a few days before the sinking. The specific weapon used was a North Korean manufactured CHT-02D torpedo, of which substantial parts were recovered.“

According to the same essay, the Chinese view is as follows:

“During talks between the American and Chinese governments in late May of 2010, Chinese officials claimed that the sinking of the Cheonan had been as a result of an American rising mine, which is moored to the seabed and propels itself into a ship detected by sound or magnetics, planted during anti-submarine exercises that were conducted by the South Korean and US navies shortly before the sinking. To back up their claims, the Chinese said that North Korean submarines such as the one believed to have sank the Cheonan were incapable of moving undetected within South Korean waters, and a rising mine would have damaged the ship by splitting the hull, as was done to the Cheonan, rather than simply holing the vessel as a conventional torpedo does.“

This discussion with my Chinese friends was yet another reminder that, however obvious or self-evident a point of view may seem, however strong the evidence may appear, others can – and frequently do – hold totally different positions on the same issue. In everything from international relations to personal relationships, one has to appreciate that others can sincerely hold very different views and one has to understand why this might be the case and what thinking – and even evidence – might explain that view.

In the end though, truth does matter as I have argued in my web site essay “The Reason For Truth”. In the particular case of the sinking of the “Cheonan”, truth matters because there are several routes from this incident to a more serious conflict or even a war as set out in this piece from the “New York Times”.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (4)


“The Spirit Level” (1)

June 5th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

I’ve started to read a fascinating book called “The Spirit Level” by Richard Wilkinson & Kate Pickett. This video promotes the main message:

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)


Introducing the Youth Parliament of Pakistan

June 4th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Thanks to my web site, I receive e-mails from all around the world and I derive great pleasure from knowing that material on the site is of interest and assistance to people of many different nationalities and cultures. I like to think of myself as a citizen of the world and there is something on my site about almost every nation on the globe.

Today I received an e-mail from a member of the Youth Parliament of Pakistan, an impressive young man called Ahmad Noor.  I confess than I had never heard of this organisation before, but I think the idea of a Youth Parliament is a wonderful one, especially in countries (dare I say it, like Pakistan) where democratic values are fragile and threatened.

Some 45 years ago, I was School Captain at my secondary school in Manchester in the north of England and I founded a School Council with elected representatives from every class in the school. It is never to early to learn the principles of democratic discourse and decision-making

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (1)


The Consumer Focus Extra Help Unit

June 4th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Consumer Focus – on whose Board I sit – has an Extra Help Unit located in our Glasgow office. The unit exercises our powers under the Consumer Estate Agents and Redress Act 2007 to investigate energy and postal complaints for vulnerable consumers.

In our first operational year, the EHU dealt with 7,606 cases and obtained almost £700,000 compensation for consumers through negotiation with suppliers.  My colleagues who staff the unit and deal with the complaints do terrific work and it’s good to see that effort receiving coverage in this article in Scotland’s “Herald” newspaper.

Posted in Consumer matters | Comments (0)


“The Glass Room” and the Villa Tugendhat

June 3rd, 2010 by Roger Darlington

I’ve now finished reading the novel “The Glass Room” by Simon Mawer which is largely set in Czechoslovakia before and during the Second World War.  The book was shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize last year and it is an excellent work which I’ve reviewed here.

The building featured in the book is real, even though the novel is a work of fiction. It is the Villa Tugendhat which is located in Brno in what is now the Czech Republic.

Before reading the novel, I’d never heard of the building, but I now know that in 1992 the political leaders of Czechoslovakia met there to sign the document that formally divided the country into the present separate states of the Czech Republic and Slovakia.

One of my 21 short stories is set in pre-war Czechoslovakia and you can read “The Edge Of War” here.

Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)


When will Israel ever learn?

June 2nd, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Friends of Israel (and I am one of them) must despair that the country will ever learn that disproportionate and counter-productive security operations, like the invasion of the Gaza strip and now the attack on the aid convoy, do not just cause appalling loss of life but alienate the nation from the international community and ultimately do nothing to strengthen its security.

The loss of life and the many injuries in the latest operation represent both a tragedy and an outrage. It has resulted in Israel’s allies in the region – Turkey and Egypt – having to review fundamentally its cooperation with the nation, it has immediately weakened the effectiveness of the blockade, and it must – and should – lead to a re-evaluation of the whole notion of such a blockade that punishes a whole society and not just Hamas extremists. Meanwhile the captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit is no nearer to being released as he should be.

If one makes any criticism of Israel, one runs the risk of being branded as anti-Semitic, so let me quote an Israeli – David Grossman – who, in this article, provides one of the most balanced and valid critiques of the military operation and rightly refers to:

“a clumsy and calcified policy, which again and again resorts by default to the use of massive and exaggerated force, at every decisive juncture, where wisdom and sensitivity and creative thinking are called for instead.”

When I was on holiday in Israel, I heard the saying: “If force does not work, use more force”. When will Israel realise that this approach is not just illegal and immoral but counter-productive to the achievement of peace and justice for both Israelis and Palestinians?

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (1)


Our local Hindu temple

May 31st, 2010 by Roger Darlington

A new Hindu temple has opened officially today in Wembley in north-west London. It took 14 years and cost £16 million to build. The charity behind the building of the temple is the Shri Vallabh Nidhi UK.

The temple is literally down the road where from we live and I’m looking forward to visiting it.

More information and video here.

Posted in Miscellaneous | Comments (0)


How much poverty in the UK?

May 31st, 2010 by Roger Darlington

An extract from an analysis of the most recent figures from the respected Institute for Fiscal Studies:

“The most widely used measure of relative poverty is the number of people living in households with incomes below 60% of the median. (If households were lined up from richest to poorest, adjusted for family size, the median income would be that of the household in the middle.)

On this basis, the number of people in poverty fell by 100,000 to 10.9 million before housing costs in 2008-09 (18%), but was largely unchanged on an after housing costs basis at 13.4 million (22%).

Having increased in each of the three previous years, poverty is still higher than its recent low-point in 2004–05. However, it is significantly lower than when the recent Labour Government came to office in 1997.”

You can read the full press release here.

Posted in British current affairs | Comments (0)


I have seen the future

May 29th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

I bought the iPod; I was one of the first UK purchasers of the iPhone; and I’ve always known that I would buy the latest Apple product the iPad. But I wanted to play with one first and then treat myself for my birthday next month. Sometimes delayed gratification is good for the soul ….

Last night, I visited my good friend and IT guru Eric, partly to enjoy his company and partly to try out his iPad. Like the geek he is, he took delivery of his iPad the afternoon before the official UK launch yesterday so that, by the time I saw him, he had already had the tablet computer for over 24 hours.

It’s incredibly beautiful, it’s amazingly functional, and I have to have one.

Posted in Science & technology | Comments (1)


Can anyone explain “Lost”?

May 29th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

As explained in this posting, I gave up on the television series “Lost” in the middle of the fourth series when the promised answers dd not materialise.

I was so disappointed that I didn’t even watch the concluding hours of the show – broadcast recently – because I feared that any ‘answers’ would still be unsatisfactory.

But I did want to know what it was all about and have read several comments on the ‘explanation’ – but I’m still little the wiser. Something about Purgatory? I thought that even Catholics had given up on Purgatory.

Can anyone enlighten me?

Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)