A fair account? Don’t bank on it

December 15th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

As a member of the Board of Consumer Focus, earlier this week I was invited to attend an event sponsored by the organisation and blog about it. Here is what  I wrote:

Who would have thought that one could persuade some 100 people to gather on a cold December evening to discuss the future of banking with no more incentive that a mini mince pie – but that is exactly what Sarah Brooks and colleagues at Consumer Focus managed to do at the request of the Government-appointed Independent Commission on Banking. It was the fifth and last of a series of IBC meetings with the public and, by the time it was over, it was declared the best by an intrepid individual who had managed to smuggle himself into most of them, with the IBC Secretariat declaring in a follow-up communication: “We thought that the debate went incredibly well and that the format worked better than those we’d tried elsewhere”.

So what were the ingredients for such a success? The chair was Paul Lewis, the presenter of “Money Box” on Radio 4, and he combined immense knowledge of the subject with a lively and interactive, but commanding, style. He was ably supported by an expert panel of five: Martin Taylor, a member of the Commission; Martin Lewis, creator of the website Money Saving Expert; Danielle Walker-Palmour, a director of the Friends Provident Foundation; Mark Lyonette, Chief Executive of the Association of British Credit Unions; and Mike O’Connor, Chief Executive of Consumer Focus.

The format of the event kept things moving and varied. There were three main questions for debate, but also short video clips, voting by handset, and the opportunity to complete a suggestion form. Above all, there was an engaged audience which was not backwards in coming forwards: a range of professionals from the financial services industry including some actual bankers, listeners of the “Money Box” programme, users of the Money Saving Expert web site, and participants in deliberative research commissioned by Consumer Focus – plus a few journalists.

So what were those questions.

  • Why don’t consumers vote with their feet when they’re unhappy?

Consumer Focus research showed that, in the last two years, only 7% of current account users had switched and only 17% had considered doing so. Reasons offered for non-switching included apathy, ignorance, inertia, hassle, lack of transparency over charges and rates, lack of competition between institutions, and (for some) poor credit rating. It was pointed out again and again that so-called ‘free’ banking is actually paid for by hidden charges such as the cost of overdrafts and by cross subsidisation by other products and that one simply cannot have price competition between ‘free’ accounts. One speaker asserted: “There are not good and bad banks but good or bad products”. Finally we were reminded that 1.5 million citizens cannot switch accounts because they do not have one in the first place.

  • How can we ensure that banks provide ‘public goods’ such as essential banking services?

Mike O’Connor explained that the volume of payday loans has gone up four times in recent years and called for weekly as well as monthly standing orders and made a plea for more banking services at post offices. Danielle Walker-Palmour emphasised that what those on low incomes wanted above all was control of their finances with accounts that provide control over outgoings, better advice on balances, and provision of ‘buffer zones’ . One member of the public, who had professional knowledge of the universal service requirement on the telecoms incumbent BT, made the intriguing suggestion that, if a bank exceeded a certain share of the market, then it should be obliged to accept some social obligations.

  • What is the role of smaller financial service providers?

We were advised that, as well as the five big banks and the four big building societies, there are some 30 credit unions providing financial services in the UK and credit unions are particularly strong in parts of the country like Northern Ireland and Glasgow. In many other countries, they have a much bigger share of the market than is the case in Britain. Metrobank – the first new bank in this country for some 150 years – was represented and he explained that to get off the ground involved overcoming regulatory hurdles, accessing sufficient capital, and building a strong IT platform. One member of the public opined that “Small is good” and mentioned efforts by her local council in Essex to provide banking services.

If there was one voice at the event that was loudest (both literally and metaphorically) it was that of Martin Lewis who declared counter-intuitively that “Banking is not a financial issue” by which he meant that it affects every element of our lives. He insisted: “Finance is boring – saving money isn’t boring”. He pleaded for financial education in schools to be compulsory and was supported by a teacher of maths who declared “We need consumers who can make rational decisions”.

So where does the Banking Commission go from here? It was established in June 2010 and put out an issues paper and call for evidence in September 2010 and it plans to issue an options paper in Spring 2011 and a final report in September 2011. Then it’s over to the Government.

Posted in Consumer matters | Comments (2)


The Government’s Plan B

December 14th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

It is reported today that the Coalition Government has prepared an alternative economic strategy to be activated if the economy does not recover fast enough. Elements of the Plan B are further quantitative easing, purchase of commercial bonds, infrastructure investment and tax cuts.

It would not surprise me if a Plan B proves necessary, but a reduction in the scale and speed of public expenditure cuts should be part of any alternative strategy about which I speculated in a posting two months ago.

Posted in British current affairs | Comments (0)


The planet’s seventh billion

December 13th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Sometime next year, the world will see its population hit the seven billion mark.

To see how we got here and where we’re going in population terms, watch this short video.

Posted in Environment | Comments (0)


How large are the different continents?

December 13th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

You might obtain a better idea from these illustrations.

Posted in Miscellaneous | Comments (0)


Netroots UK event

December 13th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

If you live in the UK and you’re interested in using the Net for social activism, you might want to attend this event.

Posted in Internet | Comments (0)


A Christmas treat

December 12th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

I’m not religious  – but I would love to have been here.

Posted in Miscellaneous | Comments (0)


“The Diving Bell And The Butterfly”

December 12th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

Three years ago, I read the book – my review here.

This weekend, I saw the film – my review here.

Truly a haunting and inspirational story.

Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)


The case for evolution (2)

December 11th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

A week ago, I did a posting about an essay I have written for my web site entitled “The Case For Evolution”. I felt that the web was missing a short and  accessible – and accurate – guide to this most important of scientific thoughts. Since then, the essay has benefited from a number of revisions as a result of detailed and helpful comments from my scientific friends Nick Hobson and Phil Holt.

Now we have to hope that people will read and think about the essay. In that earlier posting, I wrote:  ‘One test of the extent to which this essay meets a need will be how long it takes for a Google search on the words “case for evolution”  to bring my work onto the first page of results.’

Well, just one week on, if you put inverted commas around those three words in a Google search, the clever search engine brings it up on the first page. Don’t you just love the power of the web?

On the other hand, if you use those three words without inverted commas, the top item is a piece putting the case against evolution. This highlights the need to know good search techniques.

Posted in Science & technology | Comments (0)


This year’s Darlington Christmas letter

December 11th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

It’s written and this weekend we start sending it out with our Christmas cards to friends around the world. But you can read it now – and with hyperlinks.

It’s the famous Darlington Christmas letter and here is the 2010 edition. This is the 15th such letter to go online and, if you read all of them, you’ll be an expert on my world.

Posted in My life & thoughts | Comments (0)


Happy anniversary Angry Birds

December 10th, 2010 by Roger Darlington

It’s one year to the day since the launch of Angry Birds, the world’s most popular mobile application for casual gaming. You didn’t know that? That’s why you come to NightHawk – for fascinating insights into our complex world 🙂

I’m one of 36 million players of Angry Birds and currently I’m frustrated because I’m stuck on level 7-11. So, for a change, I’ve downloaded the Christmas version which is really rather difficult too – but just as addictive.

Don’t understand the craze? Read this piece.

Posted in My life & thoughts | Comments (0)