The end of the dream that was Consumer Focus

March 25th, 2014 by Roger Darlington

At the time of the last Labour Government, there was a grand project to pull together all the statutory consumer bodies – most representing consumers in a particular regulated sector – into one integrated consumer voice.  Ofcom resisted the inclusion of its newly-formed Consumer Panel, the Department of Transport kept Passenger Focus outside the scheme, and the possibility of including CCWater was eventually made the subject of a future statutory review.

But the relevant legislation did merge Postwatch, Energywatch and the National Consumer Council into a new body which the Act called the New National Consumer Council but the organisation itself branded Consumer Focus. Funding for Consumer Focus came from three sources: from the big six energy companies for the energy work, from Royal Mail for the postal work, and from the Department for Business, Innovation & Skills for the work on the general economy which included a bit of communications work on issues like switching and mobile.

In the run-up to the General Election of 2010, things looked pretty good for Consumer Focus. The BIS funding was reasonable given the economic circumstances and it was proposed that a new post of Consumer Advocate be created and located in Consumer Focus. Then came the Coalition Government and the so-called ‘bonfire of the quangos’ via the all-embracing Public Bodies Act.

So the review of the position of CCWater never took place, the idea of a Consumer Advocate was abandoned, and the Government decided that Ofcom’s Consumer Panel – by then called the Communications Consumer Panel – and all the work of Consumer Focus should be transferred to Citizens Advice and Citizens Advice Scotland.

Ofcom was originally willing to see the Panel go to Citizens Advice but changed its mind and instead decided to retain the Communications Consumer Panel and the Advisory Committee for the Older and Disabled but to merge them (a process which formally requires a statutory instrument under the Public Bodies Act but the relevant SI has still not been passed).

Meanwhile the work of Consumer Focus outside energy and posts was transferred to Citizens Advice a year ago with much reduced funding from BIS. The remaining parts of Consumer Focus have been rebranded Consumer Futures and transfer to Citizens Advice at the end of this month. The last Board meeting of Consumer Futures takes place today and last night there was a farewell dinner for past and present Board members of Consumer Focus/ Consumer Futures.

So, where does this leave us? In my view, it leaves us with a consumer voice in the regulated sectors which is much less well resourced and much weaker than before this grand project began. It also leaves us with a very uneven representation of consumers in different regulated sectors:  there is a statutory, stand-alone consumer voice on communications within the regulator; there are statutory, stand-alone consumer voices for transport and water outside the regulators; and there are consumer voices for energy and posts in a special unit of a non-statutory organisation.

Finally, I must declare that I am far from a disinterested observer of all this. I was the Member for England on the Communications Consumer Panel for its first eight nd a half years; I was the Greater London Council members on Postwatch for its last three years; I was a member of the Board of Consumer Focus for its first three years; and, for the last two years, i have worked with CCWater colleagues in my current role as Chair of the Customer Challenge Group at South East Water.

I wish all my colleagues well in all the consumer organisations mentioned in this posting. At this time of austerity more than ever, consumers need a strong, properly-resourced voice across the different market sectors, especially where choice of service provider is difficult, limited or non-existent. And, one way or another, consumer bodies have to work more closely together because most of the time consumers do not see their lives through the prism of a particular industry sector and often the most vulnerable face similar issues across sectors.

Footnote: This blog posting was published as a feature in the magazine “Utility Week”.

Posted in Consumer matters | Comments (0)


Word of the day: coprolite

March 24th, 2014 by Roger Darlington

When I come across a new word, I like to look it up and try to remember it . I am currently reading the J K Rowling novel “The Casual Vacancy” and she uses a word with which I was unfamiliar.

It is ‘coprolite’ which I have learned means fossilised animal dung. Apparently this is important for paleontologists but Rowling uses the world in a metaphorical sense.

More information here.

Posted in Cultural issues | Comments (0)


How all life on Earth was almost wiped out – five times

March 24th, 2014 by Roger Darlington

Thos weekend,  I watched episode 2 of the fascinating new American television series “Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey”.

This episode concentrated on evolution and referred to the five great extinctions when substantial proportions of life on the planet were made extinct.

The best known one – the Cretaceous-Tertiary mass extinction – wiped out the dinosaurs, but the most severe – yhe Permian mass extinction (nicknamed The Great Dying) – eliminated around 96% of all life forms. We are descended from the 4% that survived.

You can learn more about these great extinctions here.

Posted in History, Science & technology | Comments (0)


The pain and sorrow of saying farewell to so many books

March 23rd, 2014 by Roger Darlington

I love books. I love the look of them the feel of them, the smell of them. But we have too many – or at least my wife Vee says so.

It is true that we have thousands and that, for years now, I have been forced to adopt a policy of ‘one in, one out’. But Vee keeps pressing me to get rid of more. She says that we need the space.

This weekend, I was compelled to address the issue of our travel books – almost 100 of them. Vee was insistent that we didn’t need them – we’re not going back to those countries and, even if we did, we would want up-dated guides. In truth, I don’t even buy travel books now because they are so heavy and it is much easier to download them to my iPad.

But getting rid of books that accompanied me around the world over the past 30 years? Heartbreaking. But I had to do it. So, so sad.

Footnote (29/3/14): Now all the foreign language dictionaries and phrase books have had to go.

Posted in Cultural issues, My life & thoughts | Comments (0)


It is World Water Day

March 22nd, 2014 by Roger Darlington

For the past two years, one of my important areas of work has been in the water sector. I am the independent Chair of the Customer Challenge Group at South East Water which supplies drinking water to 2.1 million customers in Kent, Sussex, Surrey, Hampshire and Berkshire.

So my heightened consciousness of the vital importance of water makes me aware that today is in fact World Water Day and this year the focus is on the connection between water and energy.

Water and energy are closely interlinked and interdependent. Energy generation and transmission requires utilization of water resources, particularly for hydroelectric, nuclear, and thermal energy sources. Conversely, about 8% of the global energy generation is used for pumping, treating and transporting water to various consumers.

In 2014, the UN System – working closely with its Member States and other relevant stakeholders – is collectively bringing its attention to the water-energy nexus, particularly addressing inequities, especially for the ‘bottom billion’ who live in slums and impoverished rural areas and survive without access to safe drinking water, adequate sanitation, sufficient food and energy services.

It also aims to facilitate the development of policies and crosscutting frameworks that bridge ministries and sectors, leading the way to energy security and sustainable water use in a green economy.

You can find more information on World Water Day here.

Posted in Environment | Comments (0)


How to critique a political system

March 22nd, 2014 by Roger Darlington

On my web site, I have produced short guides to 11 political systems [click here]. Since there are 193 members of the United Nations, there are obviously many more political systems although, for the purposes of this posting, I am only interested in political systems that are at least partially democratic.

Comparing and contrasting political systems is a useful exercise that brings out strengths, weaknesses and nuances. On this web site, I have compared the political systems of two Anglo-Saxon nations with a special relationship: the United States and the United Kingdom [click here].

But, more generally, how should one critique a particular political system? And how does one assess how democratic a particular political system is? I have just added to my web site an essay on “How To Critique A Political System” [click here].

Fell free to critique my critique.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)


Understanding our universe (1): a review of “Deep Time”

March 21st, 2014 by Roger Darlington

I’ve always been fascinated by cosmology. How did the universe begin and develop? Where is it going? Where do we fit into the picture?

“Deep Time” is one of the shorter and most accessible books that I have read about these questions and you can check out my review here.

Posted in Science & technology | Comments (0)


Understanding our universe (2): detection of primordial gravitational waves

March 21st, 2014 by Roger Darlington

I don’t fully understand it, but I’m excited by the news this week that scientists have for the first time found convincing evidence for the existence of primordial gravitational waves – described as the first tremors of the Big Bang that created our universe and ultimately us.

As one newspaper put it: “The minuscule ripples in space-time are the last prediction of Albert Einstein’s 1916 general theory of relativity to be verified.” He would be thrilled, I’m sure. I know it’s taken a while but, after all, time is relative.

You can read more here.

Posted in Science & technology | Comments (0)


Was the loss of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 caused by something as ‘simple’ as a fire?

March 19th, 2014 by Roger Darlington

On 8 March, a Boeing 777 airliner with 239 people on board simply  disappeared and so far no evidence of a crash has been found and no explanation for the incident has been determined.

Chris Goodfellow has 20 years experience as a Canadian Class-1 instrumented-rated pilot for multi-engine planes.

Check out his reasoning here.

Posted in World current affairs | Comments (0)


A review of the documentary film “The Unknown Known”

March 19th, 2014 by Roger Darlington

American politician Donald Rumsfeld – now in his 80s – had a remarkable political career, serving four presidents and twice holding the post of Secretary of State for Defense.  He was a leading architect of the “war on terror” which led to the fiasco of the Iraq invasion. Does he have any regrets or reflections?

Erroll Morris interviewed him over 11 days for a fascinating documentary which I have reviewed here.

Posted in Cultural issues, History | Comments (0)